Fcsd: the head of the Kaluga region and the Yamal-Nenets Autonomous district – the highest rated efficiency

MOSCOW, 15 Oct. The head of the Kaluga oblast and the Yamalo-Nenets Autonomous area Anatoly Artamonov and Dmitry Kobylkin continue to lead in the rating of efficiency of governors and shared the first two places, scoring the same number of points, according to a study by the Foundation for civil society development (Fcsd).

The method of the tenth rating Fcsd built on the basis of five thematic modules. The first (basic) module integrates sociological research of Fund “Public opinion” and peer review. The second module based on the data of Rosstat. In the third module evaluates the indicators of social well-being of regions of Russia. The fourth module is based on an assessment of the economic situation in the RF subjects. The fifth module examines the media component of the activity of heads of regions.

In addition, in the method introduced additional reduction factors — NUMBER factor that evaluates the ability of regional leaders to provide conditions for the stable functioning of political parties, as well as for conducting competitive, open and legitimate elections, as well as the factor of affiliation, which is based on the assessment of the ability of heads of subjects of the Russian Federation to provide conditions for transparent economic development in the context of fair competition, and the analysis of their involvement in the activities of business entities.


In third place, according to the rating, remains the Belgorod Governor Yevgeny Savchenko, 4 Tyumen Governor Vladimir Yakushev, 5 and 6 were shared by the head of Tatarstan Rustam Minnikhanov and the head of the Kemerovo region Aman Tuleyev, typing the same number of points. 7, 8 and 9 places are occupied respectively by the head of Chechnya, Ramzan Kadyrov, the mayor of Moscow Sergey Sobyanin and the Governor of the Chukotka Autonomous Okrug Roman Kopin. Closes the top ten the Governor of Vladimir region Svetlana Orlova.

In comparison with previous study one of the top ten has changed slightly. Dozens of retired ex-Governor of Komi Vyacheslav Gaizer, who is currently on charges of fraud and forming a criminal group. Top ten Roman Kopin, rising in the rankings, right on two points. Strengthened its position Sobyanin (climbed in the ranking by 1 position), Tuleev (+2) and the event (+1).


It is noted that 78-81 place in the ranking was shared by the Governor of the Kaliningrad region Nikolay Tsukanov, the Governor of the Tver region Andrey Shevelev, the head of the Yaroslavl region Sergey Yastrebov. Completing the list of effective governors the head of the Perm region Victor Basargin (82-83) and the head of the Astrakhan region Alexander Zhilkin (82-83).


A number of heads of subjects of the Russian Federation has improved its position in the ranking, which was due to the positive dynamics according to the traditional modules, but also partly the result of lowering the positions of their colleagues under the influence of factors NUMBER of factor and factor of affiliation.

For example, the growth position of the Governor of the Amur region Alexander Kozlov was +10 points. Of them +7 points provided the effect of reduction factors on other higher officials. And an increase of +3 positions provided personal indicators the Governor of the region by thematic modules.

A similar situation exists at the head of the Chuvash Republic Mikhail Ignatyev, having improved its positions in the rating by +9 points. Lowering his colleagues have provided an increase of +6 indicators. At the same time, own indicators by thematic modules provided a +3 item.

A similar explanation of the growth of the Governor of Kostroma region Sergey Sitnikov (+11 points). Impact reducing factors at his colleagues provided him with +6 points, +5 points given thematic modules. The growth is explained by experts by the fact that the campaign for elections of deputies of Kostroma regional Duma electoral cycle in 2015 was one of the most difficult. She was under the scrutiny of the public and the media, was held in a fair and competitive fight. Suffice it to say, the Kostroma region is the only region of the Russian Federation on 13 September 2015 was early voting. The results of the elections to the regional Duma was forced to admit even non-systemic opposition.

Factor NUMBER factor contributed to a reduction (-10) in positions of senior officials of the two subjects of the Russian Federation — the Nizhny Novgorod region Governor Valery Shantsev, Governor of the Ulyanovsk region Sergey Morozov.

The reduction factor of the factor of affiliation the most negative impact on the position of the head of Republic Khakassia Viktor Zimin and the Governor of the Kaliningrad region Nikolay Tsukanov. Both applied a reduction factor of -10 points. Thus at the expense of thematic modules General decrease Zimin amounted to -6, and -4 Tsukanov paragraph (a successful campaign and victory on elections of the Governor of the Kaliningrad region provided him with high levels of traditional modules).

In the case of the head of Republic Khakassia Viktor Zimin application of the lowering coefficient associated with the approval of the office of public Prosecutor of Khakassia of the indictment in the criminal case against former Deputy head of the Republic — Minister of agriculture and food Ivan Wagner. He is accused of abuse of office and illegal participation in entrepreneurial activity.

Application of the lowering factor of affiliation against the Governor of the Kaliningrad region Tsukanov dictated three episodes.

First, in the view of the regional Prosecutor’s office addressed to the Tsukanov, it is reported that the Minister of tourism of the region Andrey Ermak lobbied for the participation of the appraiser in assessing the value of the land. Secondly, the prosecution has established the presence of corruption in the regional government issuing licenses to managing companies. Thirdly, regional management of the Investigative Committee of Russia opened a criminal case against employees of the forestry Agency of the regional government. The office is charged with illegal clear sanitary felling of relict trees.

The reduction factor of the factor of affiliation -5 points in the tenth rating was applied in respect of the higher officials of subjects of the Russian Federation: the head of the Republic of Crimea Sergey Aksenov and the Governor of Perm region Viktor Basargin, the head of the Altai Republic Alexander Berdnikov, Governor of the Voronezh region Alexey Gordeev, the Governor of the Tula region Vladimir Gruzdev, Governor of the Chelyabinsk region Boris Dubrovsky, the Governor of Tomsk oblast Sergey Zhvachkin. continue reading.

Also the reduction factor of the factor of affiliation -5 points was applied to the Governor of the Astrakhan region Alexander Zhilkin, the Governor of the Ryazan region Oleg Kovalev, the Governor of Ivanovo region Pavel Konkov, the Governor of Sverdlovsk region Yevgeny Kuyvashev, head of the Republic of Mari El of Leonid Markelov, the Governor of Sevastopol Sergey menyaylo, Governor of Samara region Nikolai Merkushkin, the Governor of the Novgorod region Sergey Mitin, the Governor of Omsk region Viktor Nazarov, head of the Karachay-Cherkess Republic Rashid Temrezov, the Governor of the Nizhny Novgorod region Valery Shantsev, said the study authors of the rating.